It's Not the Drama's Fault! Viewers' Standards Have Just Gotten Too High! Basic Info & Honest Review of the Epic Historical Drama "Munmu"
The new authentic epic historical drama Munmu has finally premiered on KBS, raising its grand curtain. Proudly using the heavy title "Epic Historical Drama" (Daeha Sageuk) shows the broadcasting station's confidence that the scale will be overwhelming and grand. In the past, sticking such a grandiose label on a domestic historical drama didn't feel awkward or exaggerated to viewers at all. We were so used to the grammar of traditional historical dramas churned out by local broadcasters, so even if the sets were a bit flimsy, as long as the story was solid and long, there was a romance in just nodding and faithfully watching it.
But as times have changed, whenever a show proudly presents itself as an "Epic Historical Drama" now, the hurdle of quality that viewers expect has skyrocketed beyond imagination. As global OTT platforms like Netflix and Disney+ took over our living rooms, Korean viewers have become so accustomed to conveniently consuming massive, big-budget foreign blockbusters from their couches. For viewers who are completely tamed by dramas with Hollywood blockbuster-level quality, it's a harsh reality that the standards for judging a domestic historical drama—made by slicing up broadcasting license fees—are completely different from the past.
Just looking at the most recently broadcasted epic historical drama, Korea-Khitan War, you could painfully feel the gap between the viewers' heightened standards and the harsh production reality. In the beginning, it showed battle scenes of a quite massive scale, seemingly proving that a huge production budget fitting the viewers' immense expectations was properly spent, which drove everyone wild. But ironically, after the early episodes, those grand war scenes practically vanished into thin air, and we were endlessly shown indoor set scenes where actors fought the war solely through their dialogue. This caused expectant viewers to be greatly disappointed and pour out criticism, leaving a bitter memory of an anti-climactic ending where even the narrative was hastily wrapped up.
In terms of scale, this ambitiously launched Munmu deals with a massive universe featuring not only the three kingdoms of Silla, Baekje, and Goguryeo but also the giant Tang dynasty across the sea. Just reading the text should make your heart swell, considering the core background is the spectacular era where Silla achieved the unification of the Three Kingdoms through a treacherous journey. Yet, strangely enough, viewers' expectations have been weirdly low since before the broadcast, and I can't erase the feeling that the atmosphere has grown cold. It leaves a bitter taste, making me wonder if the loyal fans who purely anticipated and supported traditional historical dramas—squeezed out by Korean broadcasters—have dropped off that much, exhausted by anti-climactic plots.
This cold indifference is clearly reflected in the viewership ratings as well: starting at a somewhat disappointing 4.7% for the first episode, it plummeted to 4.3% in the second, foreshadowing a rocky road ahead. If it were a trendy "fusion" historical drama, many viewers would generously overlook a lack of historical accuracy or scale just to enjoy the romance between young actors. However, when the camera pans over a battle scene in a show labeled "Epic Historical Drama" and you can't see massive crowds but only a few dozen extras flailing around, the viewers' disappointment uncontrollably magnifies. It's truly a pity to see a battlefield that should feature tens of thousands of troops directed like a neighborhood gang fight, but the only consolation is that traditional historical dramas leave absolutely no room for idol actors with poor acting skills.
The current burden of an epic historical drama is that actors must hard-carry the show, purely filling up the empty, sloppy screens—lacking from clumsy CG or insufficient extras—with their overwhelming acting skills alone. Moreover, viewers' strict standards for vocal projection and acting skills for actors in traditional historical dramas are famously high and fierce, far exceeding those for modern dramas. It's incredibly common for top actors, who swept awards and praises for acting well in modern dramas, to jump into an authentic historical drama without knowing better, only to get heavily criticized and create a dark stain on their careers because their diction or tone didn't fit. Unlike the natural, everyday tone of modern dramas, historical dramas require a uniquely solemn tone and breath drawn from deep within the stomach; failing to perfectly pull that off instantly shatters the immersion, causing a huge disaster.
While the viewers' eyes have soared to the top of the universe, unfortunately, the current broadcasting production environment is tearing at the seams trying to keep up. The biggest reason for this tragedy is, as always, the structural environment of the Korean broadcasting industry, where the production team cannot freely spend the budget to match their desired scale. Authentic epic historical dramas are practically only kept alive by the public broadcaster KBS, which takes a financial loss to make them, but the allocated budget is absurdly small compared to the massive scale required. It would be my greatest wish if a well-capitalized global platform like Netflix would pick a day and make a truly grand one, but from the perspective of cold-hearted capitalists, they probably won't invest, judging that authentic Korean historical dramas lack global box-office profitability.
King Munmu, the main title role and protagonist of the drama, is actually relatively less known or familiar to the domestic public compared to other historical heroes. There is an overflowing number of big, famous figures who were active during the era this drama is set in, such as Kim Chunchu, Kim Yushin, Goguryeo's Yeon Gaesomun, and Baekje's King Uija—names everyone knows. It's a bit unfair that he hasn't gotten his due, even though he is the true, capable historical figure who completed the great task of unifying the Three Kingdoms and proudly defeated the massive Tang army with his own strength among those prominent figures. Through this drama, the writer and director will likely present a heavy re-evaluation, properly showing the public just what a great, persevering strategist and king Munmu truly was.
Nevertheless, viewers sitting in front of their TVs still seem to be watching the drama's progression sharply with suspicious eyes, reluctant to get their hopes up. Above all, this is probably due to the fundamental doubt about whether they can properly and satisfyingly unravel this incredibly massive and complex narrative intertwining Silla, Baekje, Goguryeo, and Tang within the remaining episodes, pushing past budget limitations. I'm especially curious and concerned about how they will manage to match the large-scale war scenes—the highlight of the Three Kingdoms' unification—to the heightened standards of viewers tamed by Hollywood blockbusters. Back in the old days when Taejo Wang Geon aired, they often glossed over the scale limitations by mainly shooting tight body shots of the characters' faces.
That naive era where they could convince viewers by covering up poor directing and scale purely with the god-like individual acting skills of veteran actors is long gone. Despite this, the silver lining is that the true historical drama fans who actually tuned in to watch Munmu during its premiere week are mostly giving it positive evaluations regarding the screen quality and atmosphere. Even under budget pressure, the visual quality turned out surprisingly decent—better than feared—so there is some immersion, but the biggest unknown and key viewing point is whether this quality will persistently continue until the second-half war scenes without fizzling out. The drama Munmu is compactly planned for a total of 28 episodes—relatively short for an epic historical drama—and is currently airing every Saturday and Sunday on KBS2. Will it be able to restore the lost pride of historical dramas?
But as times have changed, whenever a show proudly presents itself as an "Epic Historical Drama" now, the hurdle of quality that viewers expect has skyrocketed beyond imagination. As global OTT platforms like Netflix and Disney+ took over our living rooms, Korean viewers have become so accustomed to conveniently consuming massive, big-budget foreign blockbusters from their couches. For viewers who are completely tamed by dramas with Hollywood blockbuster-level quality, it's a harsh reality that the standards for judging a domestic historical drama—made by slicing up broadcasting license fees—are completely different from the past.
Just looking at the most recently broadcasted epic historical drama, Korea-Khitan War, you could painfully feel the gap between the viewers' heightened standards and the harsh production reality. In the beginning, it showed battle scenes of a quite massive scale, seemingly proving that a huge production budget fitting the viewers' immense expectations was properly spent, which drove everyone wild. But ironically, after the early episodes, those grand war scenes practically vanished into thin air, and we were endlessly shown indoor set scenes where actors fought the war solely through their dialogue. This caused expectant viewers to be greatly disappointed and pour out criticism, leaving a bitter memory of an anti-climactic ending where even the narrative was hastily wrapped up.
In terms of scale, this ambitiously launched Munmu deals with a massive universe featuring not only the three kingdoms of Silla, Baekje, and Goguryeo but also the giant Tang dynasty across the sea. Just reading the text should make your heart swell, considering the core background is the spectacular era where Silla achieved the unification of the Three Kingdoms through a treacherous journey. Yet, strangely enough, viewers' expectations have been weirdly low since before the broadcast, and I can't erase the feeling that the atmosphere has grown cold. It leaves a bitter taste, making me wonder if the loyal fans who purely anticipated and supported traditional historical dramas—squeezed out by Korean broadcasters—have dropped off that much, exhausted by anti-climactic plots.
This cold indifference is clearly reflected in the viewership ratings as well: starting at a somewhat disappointing 4.7% for the first episode, it plummeted to 4.3% in the second, foreshadowing a rocky road ahead. If it were a trendy "fusion" historical drama, many viewers would generously overlook a lack of historical accuracy or scale just to enjoy the romance between young actors. However, when the camera pans over a battle scene in a show labeled "Epic Historical Drama" and you can't see massive crowds but only a few dozen extras flailing around, the viewers' disappointment uncontrollably magnifies. It's truly a pity to see a battlefield that should feature tens of thousands of troops directed like a neighborhood gang fight, but the only consolation is that traditional historical dramas leave absolutely no room for idol actors with poor acting skills.
The current burden of an epic historical drama is that actors must hard-carry the show, purely filling up the empty, sloppy screens—lacking from clumsy CG or insufficient extras—with their overwhelming acting skills alone. Moreover, viewers' strict standards for vocal projection and acting skills for actors in traditional historical dramas are famously high and fierce, far exceeding those for modern dramas. It's incredibly common for top actors, who swept awards and praises for acting well in modern dramas, to jump into an authentic historical drama without knowing better, only to get heavily criticized and create a dark stain on their careers because their diction or tone didn't fit. Unlike the natural, everyday tone of modern dramas, historical dramas require a uniquely solemn tone and breath drawn from deep within the stomach; failing to perfectly pull that off instantly shatters the immersion, causing a huge disaster.
While the viewers' eyes have soared to the top of the universe, unfortunately, the current broadcasting production environment is tearing at the seams trying to keep up. The biggest reason for this tragedy is, as always, the structural environment of the Korean broadcasting industry, where the production team cannot freely spend the budget to match their desired scale. Authentic epic historical dramas are practically only kept alive by the public broadcaster KBS, which takes a financial loss to make them, but the allocated budget is absurdly small compared to the massive scale required. It would be my greatest wish if a well-capitalized global platform like Netflix would pick a day and make a truly grand one, but from the perspective of cold-hearted capitalists, they probably won't invest, judging that authentic Korean historical dramas lack global box-office profitability.
King Munmu, the main title role and protagonist of the drama, is actually relatively less known or familiar to the domestic public compared to other historical heroes. There is an overflowing number of big, famous figures who were active during the era this drama is set in, such as Kim Chunchu, Kim Yushin, Goguryeo's Yeon Gaesomun, and Baekje's King Uija—names everyone knows. It's a bit unfair that he hasn't gotten his due, even though he is the true, capable historical figure who completed the great task of unifying the Three Kingdoms and proudly defeated the massive Tang army with his own strength among those prominent figures. Through this drama, the writer and director will likely present a heavy re-evaluation, properly showing the public just what a great, persevering strategist and king Munmu truly was.
Nevertheless, viewers sitting in front of their TVs still seem to be watching the drama's progression sharply with suspicious eyes, reluctant to get their hopes up. Above all, this is probably due to the fundamental doubt about whether they can properly and satisfyingly unravel this incredibly massive and complex narrative intertwining Silla, Baekje, Goguryeo, and Tang within the remaining episodes, pushing past budget limitations. I'm especially curious and concerned about how they will manage to match the large-scale war scenes—the highlight of the Three Kingdoms' unification—to the heightened standards of viewers tamed by Hollywood blockbusters. Back in the old days when Taejo Wang Geon aired, they often glossed over the scale limitations by mainly shooting tight body shots of the characters' faces.
That naive era where they could convince viewers by covering up poor directing and scale purely with the god-like individual acting skills of veteran actors is long gone. Despite this, the silver lining is that the true historical drama fans who actually tuned in to watch Munmu during its premiere week are mostly giving it positive evaluations regarding the screen quality and atmosphere. Even under budget pressure, the visual quality turned out surprisingly decent—better than feared—so there is some immersion, but the biggest unknown and key viewing point is whether this quality will persistently continue until the second-half war scenes without fizzling out. The drama Munmu is compactly planned for a total of 28 episodes—relatively short for an epic historical drama—and is currently airing every Saturday and Sunday on KBS2. Will it be able to restore the lost pride of historical dramas?











.jpg)
댓글
댓글 쓰기